Insurance Appraisals for Homes in Toledo, Ohio

An insurance appraisal answers a different question than a typical sale or refinance: after a fire, storm, or other casualty, the issue is often the home's replacement cost, not just what it would sell for. These assignments can be complex, and most require the cost approach when there has been a total loss. Fortunately, we have experience with them. Altermatt Appraisal Services provides insurance appraisals for residential properties in Toledo and throughout Northwest Ohio, including Lucas, Wood, Fulton, Ottawa, Defiance, and Williams counties. Bill prepares insurance appraisals for properties in Toledo, Oregon, Northwood, Genoa, and Curtice, and throughout our service areas.

When you need an insurance appraisal

You need an insurance appraisal when a home has been damaged or destroyed, or when an insurer, adjuster, attorney, or homeowner needs a supported, independent value. Typical situations include:

  • A home has been destroyed or heavily damaged and the claim requires a supported value.
  • An insurer, adjuster, or attorney needs an independent opinion of value for a residential claim.
  • A homeowner needs a documented, independent value for an insurance-related matter.

Market value vs. replacement cost in an insurance appraisal

An insurance appraisal often has to separate market value, the most probable price a home would sell for, from replacement cost, what it would take to build an equivalent home today. The two can be very different: an older home in a modest neighborhood may cost far more to rebuild than it would sell for, and land value is part of market value but is not destroyed in a fire. Knowing which value your policy, claim, or attorney needs is the first step in setting the scope of work. Many home insurance policies are written on replacement cost, so ask your agent which figure your policy uses.

What happens during an insurance appraisal

An insurance appraisal usually combines two methods, the cost approach and the sales comparison approach, reconciled into one supported opinion of value.

Cost approach in an insurance appraisal

In an insurance appraisal, the cost approach estimates the cost to replace the improvements, considering the quality of building materials, labor costs, and current market conditions, then accounts for depreciation and adds the value of the site. When a home is a total loss, this approach is usually central.

Sales comparison approach in an insurance appraisal

Where appropriate, an insurance appraisal also uses the sales comparison approach, measuring market value from recent comparable sales of similar homes. Reconciling both approaches gives the client a fuller picture of the property's value.

Documentation for an insurance appraisal

Because a damaged or destroyed home cannot always be observed as it was, an insurance appraisal may rely on photos, blueprints or plans, permits, prior appraisals, tax records, and the owner's description of finishes and features. All of this is documented in a written report developed under the standards of the Appraisal Foundation (USPAP).

What to have ready for an insurance appraisal

For an insurance appraisal, have the property address and date of loss ready, plus the claim number and your insurer's adjuster contact if there's a claim. Photos of the home before the loss, blueprints or plans, permits, or prior appraisals also help. Other useful details:

  • Listing information, if the home was ever listed for sale.
  • A description of the home's size, finishes, and recent updates.

Insurance appraisal timeline

Insurance appraisal timelines depend on how much information has to be reconstructed after a total loss. Most reports are delivered within a few business days of the inspection, and we confirm the schedule with you or your insurer when we define the scope.

How an insurance appraisal report is used

Homeowners, insurers, and attorneys use an insurance appraisal to support claim settlements, evaluate a total-loss figure, and inform decisions about rebuilding. We handle all types of residential property, including single-family homes, condominiums, and 2-4 unit properties.

Why choose Altermatt Appraisal Services

Your insurance appraisal is done by Bill Altermatt, SRA, who earned the SRA designation from the Appraisal Institute and has been appraising homes in the Toledo area since 2004. He has been an Ohio Certified Residential Appraiser since 2007 and has completed nearly 8,000 appraisals for clients that include homeowners, attorneys, banks, credit unions, and insurance companies. You can also see what clients say on our Testimonials page.

If the damaged home belongs to an estate, see estate appraisals. If you rebuild and later want to drop mortgage insurance, see PMI removal appraisals. See all the communities we serve, and read why real estate appraisals matter in insurance.

Insurance appraisal questions

Here are the insurance appraisal questions homeowners, insurers, and attorneys ask us most often.

What is the difference between market value and replacement cost in an insurance appraisal?

In an insurance appraisal, market value is what the home would most likely sell for, including the land, while replacement cost is what it would take to build an equivalent home today. Insurance questions often turn on replacement cost, especially after a total loss.

Can an insurance appraisal be done after a home has burned or been demolished?

Often, yes: an insurance appraisal can rely on pre-loss photos, blueprints or plans, permits, prior appraisals, public records, and the owner's description to document what the home was, then develop the cost approach and, where appropriate, the sales comparison approach.

Do you do insurance appraisals for insurance companies?

Yes, our insurance appraisal clients include insurance companies as well as homeowners and attorneys.

What types of properties do you cover with an insurance appraisal?

We do insurance appraisals on residential real estate: single-family homes, condominiums, and 2-4 unit properties.

Request a quote

To request a quote for your insurance appraisal, use the short form on our Contact Us page and tell us what the appraisal is for, such as a total loss or a question about replacement cost. Bill reviews every request personally and replies, or you can call 419-754-3396. Quotes are free.

Other services we offer

If your insurance appraisal ties into other real estate decisions, Bill handles the services below too, with the same Appraisal Institute standards.